Quick summary
When founders sell a business, the conversation usually starts with valuation: the EBITDA multiple and the headline price. But in the middle market, how a deal is structured often matters more than the number at the top of the offer. Earnouts, seller notes, and rolled equity can turn a high headline price into far less cash at close. Embarc Advisors founder Jay Jung explored this on the Inspired Stories Podcast, sharing why structure drives outcomes, why earnouts so often fall short, and how a competitive process helped one client move from an expected six to eight times EBITDA to more than 12 times, all cash.
In this article
- Why the headline multiple can mislead
- Why earnouts often fall short
- How to protect an earnout
- How a competitive process improves price and terms
- Why founders shouldn’t sell alone
- Key takeaways
- Listen to the full episode
Jay Jung, founder and managing partner of Embarc Advisors, recently joined host Anthony V. Codispoti on the Inspired Stories Podcast to talk about his path from a startup founder to McKinsey and Goldman Sachs to building a middle market M&A firm. One theme came up again and again: when you sell a business, the structure of the deal can matter more than the valuation.
Why the headline multiple can mislead
Founders often hear about a peer who sold for a “really high multiple.” The number sounds impressive until you look at how much of it was paid in cash at closing.
“We look at it, and the cash at close was this much. And then they had earnouts, seller notes, and some equity. When you’re in the middle market, it’s as much about the valuation, but it’s also structure. Structure plays a bigger role than valuation.” – Jay
A headline price can include several kinds of consideration, and each carries a different level of certainty:
- Cash at close: the money you receive when the deal closes. It’s the only part of the price you are certain to collect.
- Earnouts: future payments that depend on the business hitting performance targets after the sale.
- Seller notes: a portion of the price the buyer pays you over time, like a loan you make to the buyer.
- Rolled equity: a stake in the buyer’s company, which is only worth something at a future exit.
None of these tools is bad on its own. Buyers of owner-operated businesses often use them for good reasons: to manage risks like customer concentration or churn, and to keep the seller engaged after closing. Used well, structure aligns buyer and seller so the seller can earn the full value if the business performs. But it means two offers with the same headline price can be worth very different amounts to you. That’s why Jay calls cash at close the most important number for a business owner when they sell.
Why earnouts often fall short
Earnouts are one of the most common ways a headline price gets stretched. The data on how they pay out is sobering. According to SRS Acquiom, which tracks thousands of private-company deals, earnouts pay about 21 cents on the dollar on average across deals with earnouts.
Jay’s view is that most earnouts don’t fail because buyers act in bad faith. Buyers usually want the seller to hit the earnout, stay engaged, and help the business grow. They fail because the earnout was never clearly defined.
“The buyer and the seller will align on the spirit of the earnout. But then the earnout is not well documented, not well defined. It’s not clear how it’s going to be measured.” – Jay
After closing, the purchase agreement moves from the deal team to the accountants, who follow the document exactly as written. If the agreement says the earnout will be measured under GAAP and the seller never kept GAAP books, or if no one accounted for the new overhead that comes with joining a larger company, the business can miss its targets almost from day one.
How to protect an earnout
If an earnout is part of your deal, the details decide whether you collect it. Before you sign, make sure the agreement answers these questions:
- Is it the right metric? Revenue, gross profit, and EBITDA behave very differently after a sale.
- Is the metric precisely defined? Spell out the accounting basis, including whether it follows GAAP or your historical practices.
- How will it be adjusted? Address new costs the buyer may add, such as their systems, insurance, and overhead.
- How and when will it be measured? Agree on who calculates it, when, and how disputes are resolved.
Getting these right is part of why, as Jay notes, Embarc’s clients who do have earnouts generally achieve them.
How a competitive process improves price and terms
Jay shared a story that shows how process and structure work together. A client in industrial services expected to sell for six to eight times EBITDA, the typical range in his industry. During the sale process, one buyer made a preemptive offer at nine times, a premium to the market.
Instead of stopping there, the Embarc team called every party that had reviewed the company and gave them 36 hours to submit their best offers. Six or seven buyers came back, and the bidding moved quickly.
“Long story short, they signed the LOI at over 12 times. And it was all cash. Structure matters, right? Anyone can get 12 times when there’s a big earnout. It was 12 times all cash.” – Jay
Two principles made that result possible. First, Embarc never goes to market with an asking price, because in any negotiation, you don’t want to give the first number. Second, the company’s real strengths, including marquee customers, exceptional service, and early adoption of new technology, were positioned for the buyers who valued them most. Because Embarc bills hourly, the team was free to put in the extra work that pushed the outcome beyond the first strong offer.
Why founders shouldn’t sell alone
When asked about the biggest misconception founders have about selling, Jay didn’t hesitate: many think they can do it themselves.
“I can’t even sell my condo without a real estate agent helping me. And selling a business is vastly more complicated and difficult, and the stakes are higher.” – Jay
On buy-side engagements, Jay often sees sellers with no M&A advisor at all, negotiating against experienced buyers without realizing what they’re giving up. An advisor’s job is to prepare the business, defend its earnings with a seller’s quality of earnings, run a competitive process, and negotiate the structure, not just the price.
Key takeaways
- The headline multiple is only part of the story. Cash at close is the number that matters most.
- Earnouts, seller notes, and rolled equity can align buyer and seller, but each one adds uncertainty.
- Earnouts pay about 21 cents on the dollar on average, mostly because they are poorly defined, not because buyers act in bad faith.
- A competitive process, with no asking price, can improve both the price and the terms.
- Selling a business is too complex and too important to do alone.
For more on the decisions that shape your proceeds, read 10 Common M&A Mistakes Founders Make When Selling Their Business, or learn about our sell-side advisory.
Listen to the full episode
Hear Jay’s full conversation with Anthony V. Codispoti, including his early startup lessons, building Embarc, and why the firm bills hourly, on the Inspired Stories Podcast. It’s also available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube.
Frequently asked questions
What does deal structure mean in M&A?
Deal structure is how the purchase price is paid. Beyond cash at close, it can include earnouts, seller notes, rolled equity, and escrows or holdbacks. Two offers with the same headline price can be worth very different amounts to the seller depending on their structure.
Why can deal structure matter more than valuation?
A high headline multiple can include large earnouts, seller notes, or rolled equity that may never be fully paid. Cash at close is the only part of the price a seller is certain to collect, so a lower offer with more cash can be worth more than a higher offer with more contingent payments.
How often are earnouts paid out?
According to SRS Acquiom, earnouts pay about 21 cents on the dollar on average across deals with earnouts. Many shortfalls come from earnouts that were poorly defined rather than bad faith.
How can a seller protect an earnout?
Choose the right metric, define it precisely, including the accounting basis, address how new costs from the buyer will be treated, and agree on who measures it, when, and how disputes are resolved.
What is cash at close?
Cash at close is the money a seller receives when the deal closes, after any amounts held back for escrows, earnouts, seller notes, or rolled equity. It is the most certain part of the purchase price.
Should I set an asking price when selling my business?
Generally, no. In a negotiation, you don’t want to give the first number. A competitive process without an asking price lets buyers compete and can improve both the price and the terms.
Have an offer on the table, or expect one soon? Talk with our team before you sign to understand what you’ll actually take home.
